De Monarchia By Dante Alighieri Book III Chapter V: Argument From the Precedence of Levi Over Judah.

COSTA, Lorenzo the Elder 
Adoration of the Magi 
1499
And it came to pass, that in those days there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus, that the whole world should be enrolled. This enrolling was first made by Cyrinus, the governor of Syria. And all went to be enrolled, every one into his own city. And Joseph also went up from Galilee, out of the city of Nazareth into Judea, to the city of David, which is called Bethlehem: because he was of the house and family of David, To be enrolled with Mary his espoused wife, who was with child. And it came to pass, that when they were there, her days were accomplished, that she should be delivered. And she brought forth her firstborn son, and wrapped him up in swaddling clothes, and laid him in a manger; because there was no room for them in the inn. Lk

CHAPTER V

Argument from the precedence of Levi over Judah.

1. They also abstract an argument from the word of Moses, declaring that in Levi and Judah sprang from Jacob’s loins the types of these two sovereignties, the one being father of the priesthood, and the other father of temporal rulers.1 From this they argue: The relation of Levi to Judah is that of the Church to the Empire; Levi preceded Judah in birth according to Scripture; therefore the Church precedes the Empire in authority.

2. Refutation is here easy, for I might as before overthrow by positive denial the assertion that Levi and Judah, the sons of Jacob, typified these sovereignties; but I will concede that point. When, however, they proceed to infer from their argument that as Levi had precedence in birth, so has the Church in authority, I repeat that the predicate of the conclusion is not the term of the major premise, for the one is “authority” and the other “birth,” things different in subject and meaning. There is an error, therefore, in the form of the syllogism, which is as follows: A precedes B in C; D is related to E as A is to B; therefore D precedes E in F. But F and C are dissimilar.

3. If they become insistent, saying that F follows from C (that is, “authority” from “birth”), and that in an inference a consequent may replace an antecedent (as “animal” might replace “man”), I answer that it is untrue. Many are older in years who have no precedence in authority, but are superseded by their juniors; for instance, when bishops are younger than their arch-presbyters. And so the insistence is misplaced, for they have named as cause that which is none.

[1. ]Gen. 29. 34, 35. Reference is made to the sons of Levi as men of churchly and not secular authority Purg. 16. 127. Marco Lombardo is speaking to Dante: “Say from this day forth that the Church of Rome, through confounding of herself two governments, falls in the mire, and befouls herself and her burden.” “O my Marco,” said I, “thou reasonest well; and now I perceive why the sons of Levi were exempted from the heritage.”



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

UPDATE: Virginia Beach Mass Shooter DeWayne Craddock MUSLIM CONVERT KILLED MANY AS POSSIBLE FOR LAST FRIDAY OF RAMADAN

Death Photo Of Robin Williams Dead By Means Of Autoerotic Asphyxiation?

'Kill The GAY Dog, He Doesn't Deserve To Live': Princess Hassa bint Salman On Trial In Paris For Ordering Her Bodyguard To Beat Up GAY Decorator And Force Him To Kiss Her Feet

Robin Williams' Left Wrist Was Lacerated Just As Was David Carradine's Left Wrist, Who Died By Means Of Autoerotic Asphyxiation (AEA)

Actor Robin Williams Dead By Means Of Autoerotic Asphyxiation (AEA)! "It Was A Hollywood Thing"

ACTUAL PHOTO: ISIS Beheads Rehana The Poster Girl For Kurdish Freedom Fighters In Kobane

UPDATE: Daughter's Boyfriend Murdered Parents Savvas & Amy Savopoulos And Then Burned Down The House?

Iran TORPEDOES Two Oil Tankers MT Front Altair And Kokuka Courageous In Sea of Oman

NATIONALIST GUN NUT Brian Issack Clyde, 22, Opened Fire On Dallas Federal Courthouse Wearing Black Mask And Tactical Gear

Mystery Solved In Dominican Republic Deaths: Bartender VIDEO Shows What Is Causing American Deaths At Hotel Resorts.....